Your go-to tech blog

Break the Never Name a Number First Rule: How to Determine a Salary Range That Holds Up in the Interview

A salary range is not a negotiation zone. It is a small piece of pay architecture, built months before your interview by someone in compensation who has never heard your name, and it follows rules you can read once you know where to look. Candidates who treat it as an opening bid from the employer tend to aim at the maximum, get stuck below the midpoint, and leave the process feeling that they lost an argument nobody was actually having.

This teardown takes a range apart piece by piece. First the anatomy: what the minimum, midpoint and maximum are for, and the two ratios that tell you where an offer will land. Then how to determine a salary range of your own from data, with a worked example.

Then which sources to trust, which popular negotiation rules to break, and how pay transparency laws are changing what you can expect to see before the first call. Pay rules differ by country and by state, so treat the legal notes as orientation and check the current rules where you live.

The anatomy of a posted range

Most employers group roles into levels or grades, and each grade has a band. The band has three numbers that matter. The minimum is what the company pays someone who meets the basic requirements of the level and is still growing into it. The midpoint is roughly the market rate for a fully competent person at that level; compensation teams usually set it from salary surveys. The maximum is the ceiling for people who have outgrown the level but have not been promoted.

Two ratios turn these numbers into something useful in an interview.

midpoint            = (minimum + maximum) / 2
range spread        = (maximum minus minimum) / minimum
range penetration   = (salary minus minimum) / (maximum minus minimum)
compa-ratio         = salary / midpoint

Range spread tells you how wide the band is. For professional and technical roles it is commonly somewhere around 30% to 60%; wider bands usually belong to senior or loosely defined roles. Penetration shows where in the band a salary sits, from 0% at the minimum to 100% at the maximum. Compa-ratio compares pay with the midpoint, so 1.00 means exactly at market rate as the company defines it.

The practical consequence: many companies place new hires between roughly 0% and 50% penetration, because they want room for raises over the next three or four years. Someone hired at the maximum has nowhere to go without a promotion. That is why the top of a posted range is often a number almost nobody is hired at, and why aiming at it rarely works. Aiming at the upper half of the band with evidence is a different conversation, and it is the one worth preparing.

Determining your own range with real numbers

Your own range has the same three parts as the employer’s: a walk away number, a target, and a stretch figure. Build it from at least three independent data points, adjusted for level and location, before you look at what the posting says.

Take an illustrative case, with invented but realistic figures. A product manager with six years of experience is interviewing for a senior PM role at a mid sized software company in a US city.

She collects three data points for comparable senior roles: a posted range on a similar job at another company, $135,000 to $165,000; a salary survey median shared by a former colleague in HR, $148,000; and an offer a peer received two months ago, $152,000 base. Their average is about $150,000, but the posted range midpoint is also $150,000 and the survey median is lower, so she treats $150,000 as the market midpoint for the level.

She then adjusts. Her current base is $138,000 and she wants a real move, so her walk away number is $145,000, about 5% above her current pay. Her experience fits the level well, so she argues for a compa-ratio near 1.05, which gives a target of about $157,500. Her stretch figure is $162,000.

The posting for the job she is interviewing for turns out to be $130,000 to $170,000, a midpoint of $150,000 and a spread of 30.8%. Her target sits at 69% penetration. That is high for a new hire, but defensible with her data, and she now knows exactly why she is asking for it.

Notice what she did not do: she did not anchor on $170,000 because it was printed, and she did not lower her target because the minimum was $130,000. The posting confirmed the market midpoint; her own experience decided the position inside the band. If the employer’s band had been $110,000 to $140,000, the data would have told her that the role was levelled below where she belongs, which is a conversation about scope rather than pay.

Where salary data comes from and how far to trust it

Not all salary data deserves the same weight. The useful question for each source is what population it describes and how fresh it is.

SourceWhat it actually measuresMain weaknessWeight to give it
Posted ranges in job adsThe band a specific employer budgets for one levelBands can be very wide or stretched to cover several levelsHigh for that employer, medium for the market
Self reported salary sitesWhat people chose to report, often including bonusSelf selection, mixed titles, old entriesMedium, only with 30 or more recent entries
Compensation surveys used by employersPay data submitted by companies, matched to job descriptionsUsually paid, shared only through HR contactsHigh when you can see it
Recruiter conversationsWhat recent offers have closed atRecruiters may round toward what is easy to placeMedium, ask for actual closed offers
Peer offers and colleaguesReal numbers for real rolesSmall sample, often from your own network bubbleHigh per data point, but few points

Two habits make these sources more reliable. Compare base with base: many self reported figures mix base salary, bonus and equity, which can inflate a number by 15% or more for senior roles. And date everything. Salary data older than 12 months can be misleading in a market that moved, in either direction.

When the sources disagree by more than about 10%, the disagreement is information. It usually means titles are being compared across different levels, such as a senior title at a 40 person startup against a senior title at a company with 5,000 employees. Resolve the level first, then the number.

The salary range rules worth breaking

Plenty of negotiation advice was written for a world where candidates saw no numbers until the offer. In many places that world is ending, and several old rules now do more harm than good.

  • Never name a number first. When a range is already posted, refusing to share yours looks evasive and wastes a call. A clear target inside the posted band, with a reason, moves the process forward.
  • Always anchor above the maximum. If the maximum is the grade ceiling, a number above it signals that you have not understood the role’s level. It is better to ask whether the role could be levelled higher.
  • The midpoint is the fair ask. The midpoint is the company’s estimate of the market. It says nothing about you. Your evidence decides whether you belong below, at or above it.
  • Only base salary matters. A target bonus of 15% on a $150,000 base is worth $22,500 a year in a good year. Signing bonuses and equity also shift the total, and they are often easier to move than base.
  • Ranges are fixed. Bands are reviewed, often once a year. A role that sat open for four months may have budget flexibility the posting does not show.
  • Your current salary is the starting point. In many US jurisdictions employers cannot ask about pay history at all. Your market data should be the starting point, and your current salary only decides your personal walk away number.

Breaking these rules does not mean abandoning caution. It means replacing tactics built on hidden information with arguments built on visible numbers, which tends to make salary talk shorter and less tense for both sides.

How pay transparency laws are reshaping the conversation

Over the past few years, a growing list of US states and cities has required employers to state a pay range in job postings. Colorado started in 2021; New York City followed in November 2022; California and Washington began in January 2023; New York State, Illinois and several others have joined since.

The details vary: who counts as a covered employer, whether remote roles are included, and what must be disclosed beyond base pay. The core effect is the same. Candidates in those places see a number before they apply.

In the European Union, the Pay Transparency Directive adopted in 2023 had a transposition deadline of 7 June 2026. Under it, candidates are entitled to information about the starting pay or its range before the interview, and employers may not ask about pay history. National laws implementing it differ in timing and detail, so whether a specific employer already complies depends on the country.

For the interview this changes a few things. You can prepare your range before the first call instead of guessing. You can ask how the posted range maps to levels, a question that used to sound pushy and now sounds informed. And employers increasingly train hiring managers to explain where a candidate would sit in the band and why, because current employees can see the same postings.

There is a catch. Some postings now show deliberately wide ranges, sometimes covering two or three levels, to meet the letter of the law without revealing much. Those ranges still help, but they demand the follow up question about level.

Questions candidates ask about salary ranges

Can an offer go above the maximum of the posted salary range? Rarely within the same level, because the maximum is usually the ceiling of the grade; the realistic route is asking whether the role could be levelled one grade higher, which moves you into a new band with its own minimum and maximum.

Does the salary range in a job posting include bonus and equity? In most US postings the range covers base pay only; Colorado and Washington also require a general description of benefits and other compensation, so a target bonus or equity grant usually has to be asked about separately.

What should I do if the posted range is extremely wide, such as 90,000 to 210,000? A range that wide usually covers two or three levels at once, so ask the recruiter which level the team is hiring for and what the range is for that level alone before you share your own number.

Is it acceptable to ask for the salary range in the first recruiter call if the posting has none? Yes, and it is a normal question at that stage; asking early saves both sides from a four round process that ends with an offer 20% below what you would accept.

The direction of travel is not hard to read. As more postings carry real numbers, the advantage moves from candidates who negotiate hard to candidates who can read a band, place themselves inside it with evidence and explain their level. Interviews will spend less time on guessing games and more on scope: which level the job really is, and which level you really are. Learning to determine a salary range from data is quickly becoming part of interview preparation, in the same way that researching the product already is.